Preventing another lead (Pb) in drinking water crisis: Lessons from the Washington D.C. and Flint MI contamination events
Listed on this site as “Preventing another lead in drinking water crisis: Lessons from the D.C. and Flint contamination events”
- Published
- Current Opinion in Environmental Science and Health, 2019
- Authors
- Siddhartha Roy and Marc A. Edwards, Virginia Tech
- Format
- 11-page PDF
Written by the two engineers who were inside both crises, this walks through what went wrong in Washington DC after 2000 and in Flint after 2014, and treats them as the same failure happening twice.
The uncomfortable part is the section on sampling. The federal method was routinely gamed, and the authors name the specific techniques used to produce a passing result from a failing system.
What it says
- Both crises followed a change in water chemistry made without accounting for what it would do to lead already in the pipes.
- In DC, about 42,000 children aged 2 or under were exposed after the disinfectant switch in November 2000.
- Lead service lines and goosenecks are estimated to cause 50 to 75 percent of the lead measured at the tap, with 6.1 to 10.2 million of them still in the ground across America.
- First-draw sampling was undermined until 2016 by pre-stagnation flushing, small-mouthed bottles, low flow and removing the aerator.
- In 2016, more than 5,300 water systems serving 18 million Americans failed the Lead and Copper Rule for lead.
- Flushing does not consistently reduce lead. The authors rank it below filters and testing, and well below replacing the pipe.
- They call these two cases the tip of the iceberg, and eradicating lead practically impossible given what is still in modern plumbing.
Who it is for
Utility managers, regulators, public health agencies, and anyone building a case for proactive lead pipe replacement.